KISS New York Professional Retractable Eyeliner, Luxury Intense Highly Pigmented Eye Makeup, Long-Lasting, Water-Resistant, Smudge-Proof, Smooth Gliding (1 PACK, Blackest Black)

These are my favorite eye liner!!! Absolutely love them they glide on smoothly and effortlessly. Great value for price point. Only eye liners I wear

This eyeliner is amazing. Long lasting, easy application & no smudging. Highly recommend.

Love the different shades they give you. Makes it easy to change your look for the day fir whatever the occasion may be. I live these and buy them all the time, but they are a little hard to sharpen though

Love this eyeliner. It doesn't run. Stays on all day. The color is true. I love the ease of putting it on. The tip is soft but not too soft that it smudges on your eyes. Will be a repeat buyer.

Great buy

I have had a hard time finding a dark brown pencil. These pencils are perfect. They are long-lasting at a great price. I have also experienced more expensive pencils that become dry in a short period. These have not dried out.

Very soft. Easy to smear. Doesn’t lend itself to continuity.

It does wear off so you have to keep applying it periodically during the day but other than that, I'd rather wear this product and refresh it than to purchase leading brands that stay on longer but smudge. This one doesn't smudge as bad at all.