Make Up For Ever Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 1 Graphite for Women - 0.04 oz Eyeliner

This is my second purchase of this make-up product. Worth every penny. You get what you pay for....not saying that some economical makeup products aren't any good or high price products are guaranteed to be wonderful. But this pencil I will continue to buy forever as long as I wear makeup. It is long lasting, heavy and dark, applies easily. I am glad I tried it. Thank you Amazon!

This eyeliner pencil stays in the waterline very well. It’s not good on the eyelids because it will smudge and transfer. If you need a great waterline eyeliner, this one works very well and is long lasting.

Favorite eye liner! I have Asian eyes and sweat a lot so I need the most water proof eye liner I can find that isn’t liquid. This has been my go to for years. Only thing I wished was that there was some warning that it was almost out of pencil, it comes as a surprise to me every time.

Terrible eye liner. Doesn’t sharpen well at all. I’m unable to get it to sharpen. Money and time wasted. Go back to the drawing board!

This pencil works pretty well for not smudging. I've had a hard time finding smudge-proof eye liner. It still smudges a little bit 2nd half of day but not terrible.

Goes on easily ~ stays on and stays put ~ is not a harsh looking product ~ has a soft effect and looks very natural. I use it on my top lid along the waterline. I've used Thrive eyeliner for several years and always loved it, but it is a bit harsh looking and this one has a softer, muted look so I'll definitely be ordering it again as needed.

Disappointed that it smudged and smeared and did not stay in place. Also very thick when applying.

Doesn't stay on as advertised --total waste of money.