Salt Water Taffy 2 lb. Traditional Assortment

Arrived wrapped with a personalized gift tag! So fresh and the taste was classic seashore taffy. My husband wanted more pull, but I enjoyed this softer version with some pull that will not rip your teeth out. My husband brought some to work, and all his co-workers LOVED it. This candy brought back so many memories. My Nagymama lived in Rio Grande, New Jersey. No matter where "your" taffy comes from, it has to be from Jersey. Holla!

This is Shriver's Salt Water Taffy from Ocean City, New Jersey. This is excellent salt water taffy. This taffy is fresh with great flavors. A nice mix in a 2 lb box. This isn't the mass market taffy you get in the average grocery store. If you are a taffy fan or know someone who is, this is the stuff to get either for yourself or as a gift. You won't be sorry.

I ordered this as a Christmas gift for my dad. He has fond memories of growing up in New Jersey, and I wanted to give him a taste of home since we live so far away now. This came gift wrapped in lovely paper and ribbon. What a sweet and unexpected touch. Thank you, Shriver's!

I have ordered Schaefer’s twice before and it was great. This time what I got was a gooey mess. However, after putting it in the freezer it hardened up and I could snap it in half and let it soften in my mouth. I moved it to the fridge and I was pliable but still separated from the wrapper easily. Good stuff.

OMG, the taffy is wonderful. It brings back so many good memories of my childhood along the boardwalks in Jersey. Such soft and good tasting taffy in flavors that actually taste real.

This is absolutely the best taffy I’ve ever had. The flavors are amazing and true. Definitely worth the cost.

Alot of the pieces were stick and hard to unwrap.The flavors are good but for the price I didn't expected the stickiness.

What a horrible waste of money. You cannot unwrap the taffy - it is sticking to the paper. Your choice is to eat the inner waxed paper wrapping or only eat a portion of the taffy - whatever you can scrape off without getting paper. I thought that maybe it was due to temperature, so I put them in the refrigerator. The paper then comes off cleanly, but the taffy is hard as a rock. Taken out of the fridge, and back at room temp, it's sticking again. It's not like it was hot when I ordered - it's fall. Temps are 60s - 70s. They charge $12 to ship!! If it needs climate control then ship it that way!