MAYBELLINEUnstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Brown Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Apply, Smooth Glide, Up to 24 Hour Wear, Cinnabar

My go to everytime. Love the color, durable and super easy to apply

This DOES NOT smudge, at all. I can wear it for 8 hours and it still looks refreshed and perfect. 🩷🩷

Why did you pick this product vs others?:Glides on easy and stays all day. A good choice for an older womanThickness:It's easy to make a thick line or a thin oneSoftness:It's pretty soft and glides on easy

Very Smooth but NOT waterproof.I have very oily skin so Im always trying to find a liner tht WONT smear. I like KAT VON Ds liners but they dry to fast b4 i even get to play with it.I wore this and its doooo easy ti apply. Very milky.l but i noticed after 8 hrs of wear product was missing & smeared. Not crazy bad but noticeable :(Ill keep searching.

Maybe it's Maybelline lol... Good product

My favorite! Easy to use, twist up eyeliner. Nice dark black (onyx) color. Doesn't run or smear, even when I use eye drops. It does of I rub my eye, but thats typical. Thin tip, lasts quite awhile. A little smaller than a pencil.

This is the only eyeliner I can use that does not irritate my eyes, and, unfortunately it is becoming harder and harder to find. I really like that it stays on all day without wandering down my cheek or making eye goobies . And probably part of the reason it is hard to find is that I like the sapphire color because I have kind of pale eyes and the deep blue is not as stark as the black color nor as blah as the brown. I don't think subtle is as popular as it used to be.

Its ok, but doesn't draw on very well. Its very light, almost like its dried out but looks normal. It also smears after a few hours