URBAN DECAY24/7 Waterproof Waterline Eyeliner Pencil - Eye Liner for Tightlining + Defining, Smudge-Resistant, Transfer-Resistant, 24HR Wear, Long-lasting Creamy Neutral Shades, Vegan - 0.04 oz

This eye liner is terrific! First, it goes on smooth— no tugging of skin. Second, it creates a definite line, (which can also be smudged, if you like), that stays put all day. No reapplication needed at all. Third, comes off easily with soap and water. Finally— the color is outstanding. I have green eyes and this grey liner is perfecto! Highly recommend.

I feel like this liner is one of the best out there. The texture of the liner is just a little less creamy than the regular UD 24 hr liner, so I actually prefer it because it's easier to get a sharper line when I want to be right up on the lashline/tightline. No irritation after several uses, and was able to remove it relatively easy for being waterproof. It held up to the heat & humidity in New Orleans with no smudging.

As a 60 yr old I really like this product. It glides on and goes on well on my waterline. Highly recommend.

Stays on all day but doesn't stay on water line conpletly without looking slightly over done for more then a few hours. I felt like eyeliner stick broke to often for the price if it would last longer it would be worth the price I personally think it's a bit expensive for the value but it's defiantly one if the better eyeliners I've used

Smooth, soft, easy to apply. Glides on and stays on. Sun's Out metal sharpener works best. I gotCool Coyote and it's a neutral taupe and I love it.

Don’t waste your money does not come with a sharpener and when I finally did sharpen it, some of the wood splinters went into my eye. Horrible product. Do not recommend esp for the heafty price.

A FAVORITE in my makeup drawer! Lasts a really long time with no smudges!

I love the color. The eyeliner pencil came in with a broken tip. The liner itself is soft and smudges. I did not return hoping to use the pencil. Will not buy again.