Exclusively Dog Chewy Training Treats Bacon Apple Flavor Grain Free Gluten Free, Made in The USA, 6 oz.

At least that is how my dog reacts. She thinks fish are the greatest thing in the world. Apparently these peanut butter treats are also the greatest thing ever.They still smell of peanut butter even a month after buying them. It’s a strong good scent that I can deal with, unlike fish. She can have fish for dinner. She will have peanut butter treats for playtime.This is the first item I decided to subscribe to because her reaction and joy at these treats is that great.

The size of the treats work well with the Furbo. Not sure if it because they are so small but the Furbo shoots out 2-3 pieces each time we reward our dog. That's not really a reflection on the product quality but rather how they work with the Furbo. And it keeps our dog happy to get more than one treat at once. He loves them.

I normally buy these for my dogs at Fleet Farm. I live in the country so it's not always easy to get there. The price on Amazon seemed similar so I thought it would be more convenient to order. Normally these are chewy and they seem rock hard. I'm hoping my dogs will even eat them.

My dog seemed to enjoy them but they seemed tougher than other treats we have tried. He will eat anything but when offered other treats at the same time, he will eat other treats first. They were not expired, but seemed drier.

These treats are not chewy. They are as hard as a rock. I think they are old, but I can't tell because there is not sell by date to be found on the package anywhere. My dog won't touch them.

Training treat are wonderful rewards for teaching and praising your puppy when they do what is asked of them. These tasty treat are easily palmed and are small enough to be placed into pockets for frequent rewards. Even our fussy eater love these treats. Not sticky or crumbly, travel well. I cannot keep them in the house! Both our "kids" love these treats.

We ordered these treats for our puppy and the treats, though advertised as “chewy,” were so hard, our puppy wouldn’t touch them. Amazon kindly sent us a replacement bag. We received the new bag, and sure enough, the same hard, not chewy quality. We tried returning and we got a message from Amazon of, “not eligible.” Do not waste your money, unless your dog enjoys eating rocks.

I bought these with the understanding they only had one ingredient: Chicken. I had that understanding because in the description it says the only ingredient is chicken. The first ingredient isn’t even chicken. I spent a long time trying to find healthy treats for my dog so it’s pretty frustrating to find out these aren’t even healthy.