12pcs Nabi Retractable Waterproof Black Eyeliner (Wholesale Lot)

Not waterproof not smuged proof...but it's bold black nice for biggners

I've been buying and using these for years and while they are definitely not waterproof or smudge proof, they are excellent. Smooth, rich color that goes on easily. This is definitely the best deal in town.

Definitely not recommended & smear so much

honestly its a basic black twist eyeliner. it is a true black. do not twist it up too high or it will break ! i use it in my water line almost everyday and i have one complaint, its waterproof and not smudge proof. it does not last 100% all day so throughout the day i would have to wipe the outer corners of my eye. ONE THING TO NOTE IT IS THE SOFTEST EYELINER IVE EVER USED. do not try and use this on your eye lids CAUSE IT DOES NOT DRY DOWN and you will have transfer! its perfectly size so I can literally just throw it into my server apron or my purse. i recommend this cause its not the perfect eyeliner but it gets the job done

Great product for the price! The eyeliner is not as fine pointed as some would like, but it works for me. It is waterproof, but if you rub it right after you apply it, it may smear. Personally I like this, because if I put too much on, I can quickly wipe it off. It is waterproof because it stays on for at least two days. It is not heavy duty waterproof. Black shows up the most on my eyes, which is what I like. I like this eyeliner because it is easy to make it look more natural, if that makes sense. The fact that it is retractable is super easy to use and a lot softer on the skin than a pencil, I think. All in all, I am satisfied with my purchase. For those with greasy eyelids, it does help to put foundation, powder, or eye shadow on first before applying the eyeliner.

This is my 2nd pack of eyeliners I have purchased in the past 5 years. The 12 pencils last a while. I disliked how the Maybelline ones are over $4 each and seriously these Nabi ones last just as long at a fraction of the cost. It's so super affordable that you can put one in your purse, one at work, keep some and give some away. At less than $1 each, these are way superior to the Target cheap lines like e.l.f. or Wet and Wild. I also have been allergic to an Avon brand eyeliner, but not these. I cannot recommend these enough! They stay on pretty well. There will still be a little smudging at the end of the day, but nothing a little wipe of the under eye with a q tip or tissue and reapplication of the liner!