tarte double take eyeliner – 2-in-1 Pencil Eyeliner for Bold All-Day Wear, Waterproof, Easy to Apply, Vegan, Cruelty-Free

This is the best eyeliner extremely black like I love it to be!!! Smooth going smudge resistant the pencil side goes on like a gel. The pen side is so fabulous very back in Appearance waterproof the Brush is very soft and strong you can’t go wrong with this beauty product. The price is amazing.

Best eyeliner. Love the dual tip. The liquid pen is very thin, making it easy to apply. Stays on fairly well throughout the day. I wouldnt say its water resistant as it comes off very easily with water and a q-tip. Safe for my sensitive eyes.

Very easy to work with if you do different eyeliner styles thanks to both tips. Pretty smudge resistant and not too deep of a black color which is something that happens a bit too often for a bit of a paler person like me.

I love this eyeliner, it doesn't run too long and it's really waterproof I fought a lot to find a good eyeliner that I really don't leave the house if I'm not outlined and I'm loving this I already have my third purchase and I think I married him HAHA I WILL NOT BUY ANOTHER ONE OTHER THAN THIS

Works well but smudges easier than expected

I had this sitting in my cart for a long time and finally purchased it. shockingly good eyeliner. I used to use liquid but as I got older it started being too hard to get the straight line that I like. so I switched to the kind in the little pot that you brush on. used that for a long time, until I finally tried this. swipes right on in a straight pretty line just like when I was in my early 20's. doesn't irritate, doesnt smudge, stays on all day all night, and washes off cleanly and easily. took a few minutes off my makeup routine, which i can definitely appreciate. Haven't tried the pencil side yet and still curious how long this will last before it starts drying out. I'll update when I find out

Previously I purchased this item at full price elsewhere. Its a great eyebrow liner. I have been purchasing it here at a much lower price. I last purchased this 2.5 weeks ago. I apply it to my brows daily. Today I noticed that the pencil application is already adios. It tells me that there is something amiss here. I can no longer recommend the product due to lack of longevity. What gives? Waste of money!

Application is easy for both the liquid felt tip and the gel liner. The color payoff is good, dark black on both formulas. The liquid does stay in place despite water and sweat on the lid, however, after 10 minutes of applying, it runs underneath my eye and I look like a racoon. Even just a little lining of my water line with the liquid makes me look like I have a black eye. The formula is so waterproof that removing it can be quite tough. Even with makeup remover (micellar water, oil based, remover wipes), it takes quite a bit of work. I love that it comes with 2-in-1 so great for traveling and the packaging is sturdy.

Took too many tries to remove with makeup remover, and soap. Gave up and had to try again the next morning after sleeping with raccoon eyes! Sent back!