Erinde 4 Colors Eyeshadow Stick, Eye Brightener Stick, Shimmer Creamy Eye Shadow Makeup, Long Lasting Waterproof Glitter Highlighter Eye Liner Pencil Set

Initially I was disappointed when I received, realized it was not theThrive product o thought I ordered. However, figured I give it a try when I realized the price. Love!! Love!! Love!!, goes on great..just glides on, love the colors, love the whisper of shimmer/shine, has a creamy soft feel….but stays put!

Great product. Slides on smooth and stays on allday.

I was very disappointed in this product. I did not read description clearly. Because of the color of tube I assumed it was Thrive brand. I tried the product and not pleased. Shadow did not show up. Hard to apply.

The colors are nice but they do seem somewhat cheap. They don't come sharpened and the color stick falls out of the pen. It does go back in but still. That is what I feel is cheap about them.

I just received these after using Thrive and here’s what you need to know: -The ingredients are entirely different, so no, it is not just a manufacturer offering the same products in different packaging. -The off-brand does not go on as smoothly, nor does it blend as easily. Think of it more like a waxy crayon, while the Thrive glides on like a watercolor. -The color pay off is about the same, and the colors are very pretty. -This brand creases (probably partly because of the waxy texture.) -The stick of product is smaller in diameter and two have already broken after first use. The Thrive is definitely more durable, and has not broken on me yet after a few months of use. Overall, I would say you get what you pay for. These really are not bad for the price, but they are not nearly as good as the Thrive. If you’re just looking to try other colors, have fun with these! But for better quality makeup, probably invest in the Thrive.