5PCS Dual-Ended Colored Eyeliner Stamp Pen Set – Waterproof, Smudge-Proof Liquid Eyeliner with Butterfly, Star, Flower, Heart & Moon Stamps – Long-Lasting Winged Eye Makeup for Beginners & Pros

I got these eyeliners for my teenager. I thought the colors looked fun, and since one of them is orange it would be perfect as it's one of her school colors.These eyeliners are ok. It's a cute idea. Th eyeliner comes out a bit thick, which I guess is good in her case she needs to pack it on to be able to see it at all. These pastel shades are so light they don't show up that well on pale skin. Maybe as Summer comes and she gets a tan. They look better on darker skin. The stamps are a bit on the wonky side and don't come out nearly as neat, and we'll, legible as in the listing photos.

Why did you pick this product vs others?:Does not show up well even if your tan or with a dark complexion .

I honestly thought this set of eyeliner pens might be too young for me, or inappropriate for wearing at my professional job. But, I was wrong. I think if I were younger, I would probably be a lot bolder with thicker liners and using all the cute stamps on my lids. For me, I loved how I could blend the pastel shades into my natural eyeshadow for a fresh look that didn't make me look like I was fifty-something going on sixteen.My favorite is the lavender. I smudge it lightly against pale shimmery copper shadow.Sometimes I am overly sensitive to eye makeup, but I have been using this three days in a row with no irritation. I am sold on these pens and will continue ordering them.

These are funky colors. The liner goes on smoothly and seems to stay on without smudging (needs a minute to dry). Not waterproof - was able to fully remove with just water. The shape stamps are cute but unless these are used for stage makeup, I can't imagine using them.

Poor quality! Barely see it on my face

I think these pretty pastel liners would show up better on somebody who has a deeper skin tone than me. You can see in the picture that I swatched a couple of the colors, I have also used the other end to show what the stamps look like. You can kind of see the butterflies which are the green ones and the circle around them should not be showing, but that is difficult to accomplish with any of the colors I've tried. The design part of the stamp should be raised up more to avoid this. The lavender stamps are supposed to be Crescent moons. They barely even show up on my skin and also include the ring. The liner tip is a stiff brush pen, you can be very precise with the tip and I was able to make a wing that looked decent on my eyes. The liner does dry down nicely and does not smudge to the touch. I would say these are best as a shadow/liner but the stamps are pretty pointless.

This eyeliner works quite while. The tip is a little thick for my taste but I usually use a very thin tip. It went on smooth and the colors match their pastel tubes. I did not have any negative impact to my skin, no irritation. Once it dried, it did not smear at the slightest touch and was easy to remove with a light make-up remover. The only thing that doesn't really work with these eyeliners are the "stamps" I could not get one stamp to come out clean, even on my hand. If you are purchasing for the stamp, you may be disappointed but, otherwise, these are fun, unique eyeliner colors that work well.

The colors are very beautiful and show up well on my skin tone. I'm hispanic with a slightly tan/olive complexion and I feel like this type of pastel color really pops on my skin color. The stamp shapes were cute, but they need a little bit of cleaning up after applying. The rim of the stamp sometimes shows up around the design and has to be cleaned off with some makeup remover.