365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, Unsweetened & Unsalted, Stir and Enjoy, 16 Ounce

I can’t believe I’ve been eating peanut butter with added sugar my whole life. I originally came across this while looking for a healthier peanut butter to introduce to my daughter as she started solids, and I loved that the only ingredient is dry roasted organic peanuts, nothing else. I waited until I finished my first jar before writing a review, and by then I had already signed up for Subscribe & Save because I knew I’d be buying it again. At first, I wasn’t sure how I felt about the thinner consistency compared to traditional peanut butter, but it’s actually become one of my favorite things about it. It’s easy to spread on toast, blends easily into smoothies and yogurt bowls without clumping, and mixes smoothly into foods when I’m preparing it for my daughter. The flavor is delicious too. The first time I tried it, I definitely noticed the difference since I was used to peanut butter with added sugar. But after a few uses, I actually started to prefer the fresh, natural peanut flavor. Now I don’t miss the added sugar at all. Just make sure to stir it well, especially when you first open the jar and again as you get closer to the bottom. Since it’s made with just peanuts, the natural oils separate, and giving it a good mix keeps the texture consistent throughout. If you’re looking for a peanut butter with a clean ingredient list and great flavor, I highly recommend this one.

365 Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is a great substitute for the unhealthy peanut butter we grew up with. After taking the Red Pill and realizing that almost all of our processed foods are contaminated with seed oils and high fructose corn syrup, all of those great tasting peanut butter snacks became a thing of the past. Even the simple peanut butter and jelly sandwich became off limits because of gluten, preservatives, seed oils and HFCS. But now the Whole Foods Market brand 365 offers a cost-effective way of again enjoying all natural and organic peanut butter. The 365 peanut butter is watery and the oil does separate. Also, there are hard parts at the bottom and sides of the jar. Use your butter knife or spoon to scrape the bottom and sides so you get all the solids mixing. Then keep the peanut butter in the refrigerator. Stir before each use, and you will maximize the thickness. The taste is great. Better than I remember. I spread it on gluten free organic seed flour crackers. It is like heaven. I just need to find some organic fruit jam, and I can have a peanut butter and jelly sandwich for the first time in a decade. Thank you, Whole Foods and Amazon, for bringing this to our lives.

This peanut butter is very good. Price is excellent. You will not be disappointed. Regular jar packaging which allows it to come fresh. I bought it because it only has 2 grams of sugar.

I was a little disappointed in this product because of the deceiving information. The product states creamy peanut butter, while in fact, there are plenty of chunks of peanuts throughout. That being said, the peanut butter tastes good, It's just: buyer beware.

Good tasting peanut butter. The oil separates when warm so I mixed it and put it in the refrigerator so it kept it thickened and didn’t separate. Organic and plant based.

Surprising. It is NOT creamy. Chunky is more like it, with smaller chunks. Tastes okay. I mix peanut butter with my drill and beater before refrigerating. This one required a LOT of beating. And it still wasn't smooth. It even looked like there might be a couple whole peanuts in there at the start. It's got peanut bits all through it that can't be easily blended out with my beater. :-( Gritty, not smooth.

tastes good and smooth. nice. thanks.

I read the reviews. I read the label that said, "Stir It Up" so I dug my spoon the the bottom of the jar and stirred it up. It was delicious. It tasted like eating roasted peanuts! I did not miss the added sugars or salts that other brands may add to their peanut butter.