e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented, Coffee

Firstly, while applying, I had to rub the pencil a lot to be visible on my waterline. Secondly, it smells like crayon, as if the product has gone bad. Such a bad product - Not expected from E.L.F cosmetics.

great product nice colors

This is a very nice little eyeliner, especially for such a budget-friendly item. It glides on smoothly, and stays put. The taupe color looks natural, not artificial, with my grey/white hair. I’ll buy it again.

They really mean smudge proof when they say it. Which is great for long lasting wear, but… If you make a mistake, you’ll really have to get in there with make up remover.

I'm not a huge e.l.f fan but this eyeliner impressed me. It's soft and silky. The color is spot on. Application is easy and it looks amazing on. The longevity is fine for all day as long as you don't cry. In that case it provides racoon eyes. This is a good item at a good price point I recommend this eyeliner!

This is a true non-smudge liner that is soft enough to blend. It also does not irritate my sensitive eyes. After trying the high end brands at 5X the price that are not non-smudge as they claim, I will stick to this one - great value!