Thrive Causemetics - Infinity Waterproof Eyeliner Shade: Lauren (black matte)Pencil

This is the best eye liner ever! If you want a good liner for the waterline this is it!

Goes on easily

As an older woman this is by far the easiest to apply and stays on all day

Glides on smooth

Great

I just loved it 😍 great thickness, great color

This brand was my go to for eyeliner and mascara. It’s straight up fallen off the face of the earth in quality. The eyeliner pen doesn’t even apply to dry eyelids. I thought at first it was my eyeshadow, but I’ve used it on bare eyelid as well.. I don’t understand why it’s not smooth product like in the past. It is too dry and it literally doesn’t glide on anymore. Maybe I received a bad batch? I tried cutting it off and sharpening the end but it still doesn’t apply smooth like my other pens did. I will be shopping else where now

At first it went on nicely and stayed on, which was very good. When I wore it down and tried to extend it a big piece fell out. I twisted it once more and another piece fell off. I feel I’ve put lost half the product and won’t buy again