Marcelle Gentle Eye Make-Up Remover Pads, Sensitive Eyes, Waterproof Makeup Removal, Hypoallergenic, Fragrance-Free, Paraben-Free, Alcohol-Free, Cruelty-Free, 85 Pads

I typically dislike makeup removers specifically intended for waterproof makeup, because they leave a greasy film on my skin after using, but this one is not like that at all. I have a number of contact allergies, so I've been paying closer attention to the ingredients in my skin-care products, and of the makeup removers I looked at on the various apps like EWG, Yuka, SkinSafe, and INCI, this one seemed like it had the safest ingredients. Incidentally, the regular version of this makeup remover has salicylic acid in it, which isn't considered safe to use on the eyes. The pads aren't that wet, and I wish they had just a tad more liquid (this is my first jar, so maybe the next one will be wetter). I prefer them not to be too wet though, because then less of it seeps into my eyes. One side of the pad has a slightly rougher surface than the other, and I use that side when I first clean each eye, resting it on my lid and lashes for a few seconds before using the texture to "grab" onto the mascara and remove it. The smoother side I use to do a final swipe to clean eyeliner and everything else from the skin in my eye area. I wear tubing mascara, for reference, not traditional waterproof mascara, which (like most things) tends to be very irritating on me. My eyes feel clean after using this, which is saying a lot. I always do a final wash around my eyes and the rest of my face soon after, using a nonfoaming cleanser, so I can't say how well these pads would work if one wanted to immediately reapply makeup, but I suspect that these pads would work better than other makeup removers I've used. I wouldn't recommend it, though, since the concentration of ingredients that is allowed by law tends to be higher for products that are meant to be rinsed from the skin, and bloodshot eyes aren't a good look on me! Anyway, so far I'm really happy with these, and wanted to share my experience in case it helps someone else!

I love this makeup remover. The round cotton pads are just the right size and do a great job of removing eye makeup. I will continue to purchase them.

Gentle on my skin, but immediately effective. Removes all of the waterproof mascara smudged under my eyes with one, gentle wipe. I have sensitive skin but this has not been a problem for me. The container has kept it's moisture over time too.

These work well, still take a few swipes to remove market they what I like most is that they are so gentle!

I’m really impressed with these oil-free eye makeup remover pads. They take off mascara, eyeliner and eye shadow without any tugging, and don’t leave any greasy residue. It also does not get in my eyes! It never stings and the pads are gentle on my delicate skin around my eyes. I store the pads upside down to keep the top ones moist. I have these on subscription, so I never run out!

I used the same oil-free eye makeup remover for 20 years but this is much better. I wouldn't use anything else.

The best eye makeup remover for waterproof mascara. Takes it off in a couple seconds with no eye irritation.

The product itself is good but it sat all day in my mailbox and I was not notified of the delivery - opened the jar and eye pads hot and dried out

This is non-oily and completely removes my waterproof mascara! You can use one pad for two eyes, but I usually use one pad per eye. I will never stop using this product! It’s gentle on my skin as well.

This stuff works miracles. So gentle and leaves your face hydrated and glowing all while fully cleansing the face.

I would give this 5 but they're just so tiny!! I'm not sure why they're so small. They work well but unfortunately I have to use more than one to remove my make up which makes the jar finish fast. Great price point as well

Remove all eye makeup, even waterproof mascara! Highly recommend. Is now a must have

Tons of pads. Takes off my stubborn waterproof mascara really well. Doesn't irritate my eyes