99 Ways to Tell a Story: Exercises in Style
E**W
Nice try but no cigar
A comic book that ranges across a largely redundant exercise in style. A man gets up from his desk, closing his laptop and walks into his living room. There is a spiral staircase through which he hears his girlfriend calling to ask the time. He responds with the time - 1:15. He crosses to the kitchen, goes in and opens the fridge door. He stands there for a moment, unable to remember what he came into the kitchen for. That's the whole story, and Matt Madden ranges through 99 other ways of telling the same story. Many of them are drawn with wonderful inspiration - my favourite being the Krazy & Ignatz version Esk Her Size end Style (exercise in style) - five all too brief panels during which Krazy Kat gets his customary brick to the head - cue heart floating above him - there is nothing he loves more, but then along comes the jailer to put his `sweetheart' mouse in jail. If you haven't seen the original Krazy & Ignatz comics (by George Herriman), it won't compute. As a play on the business of style it is beautifully redolent of the original comics which only became popular after he stopped drawing them. Furthermore, this version of the story has very little in common with the original. It's all down to Raymond Queneau (b.1903, d.1973), an intellectual who founded the Ouvroir de litterature potentielle (otherwise known as Oulipo). One of Queneau's most influential works is Exercises In Style, which tells the simple story of a man who sees the same stranger twice in one day. It tells that short story in 99 different ways, demonstrating the tremendous variety of styles in which storytelling can take place. This book is Matt Madden's graphical story adaptation of the book's concept. It works well in some contexts, especially the Underground Comix version, which cleverly reworks the story as that of a hippy, but it doesn't quite have the punch of the written versions, which used rhetorical tricks and terms such as metaphor, negatives, anagrams, Alexandrines, comedy, philosophy, etc. Madden has to work within the comic book ouevre, which has far fewer tropes that can be worked as different styles, and was, anyway linguistically based.
T**E
Excellent Resource
The media could not be loaded. Fantastic resource for my MA Illustration, a thorough exploration of ways to depict story
M**V
Exercises in sheer artistic play
Based as it is on Raymond Queneau's marvellous and erudite 'Exercise in style' this play of comic narratives on a simple set of variations spun out on a single scene is pure delight.I defy anyone to remain unmoved at the sheer inventiveness of styles and variations.Like a comic version of Beethoven's Diabelli Variations - or dare I say it: Bach's Goldberg Variations.Whatever the associations go out and get it.You will not be disappointed.
C**R
99 Ways to tell a story
Bought this as a present, and didn't have time to read it properly, just flicked through it. Liked the concept, and seemed interesting/fun from what I could gather.
B**N
Five Stars
Excellent stimulus.
S**Y
One Star
Utterly useless
E**Y
Five Stars
Nice to read on the loo...
B**Y
A Mad(one) indeed!
Quite simply, one masterpiece inspired by another! As clever, thought-provoking, funny, and occasionally damn right eccentric as is Queneau's book, this is essential reading - or should that be viewing? . A near perfect example of an educational tool disguised as entertainment, this is in no way constrained by beginning, middle and end but is full of Borgesian/M C Escher infinities. But mostly it's just fun!
Trustpilot
2 days ago
5 days ago