24/7 Waterproof Waterline Eyeliner Pencil for Tightlining

One of my all-time favorite eyeliners! I have quite a few Victoria Beckham eyeliners, but I always find myself coming back to the classic Urban Decay 24/7 liner. Legend is perfect for my upper lash line, tightlining, and even my waterline—which is where most eyeliners fail me. It actually stays put without smudging or disappearing halfway through the day. Creamy, easy to apply, and seriously long-lasting. A staple in my makeup bag!

It is the best eyeliner I have ever purchased. The color is as described, texture great. And it lasts until I take it off. I have no complaints about this pencil . Costs more than other pencils I have bought , but it is better quality . So it is worth it. I bought two more today.

This is the only waterline pencil I can put on at 8p and still have it perfect at 4a. Long-lasting, durable, creamy application, and SUPER black. Have bought many times now

I purchased the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil hoping to find a waterproof, long-lasting eyeliner that would stay put when tightlining. After reading so many glowing reviews claiming it was the best, I had high hopes for this product. Unfortunately, it just wasn’t the right fit for me. The pencil is too thick to apply precisely along the upper waterline, making it difficult to use effectively for tightlining. While it may work well for other eyeliner applications, it didn’t meet my needs. For the price and all the rave reviews, I was disappointed. I’m still searching for a truly waterproof, smudge-proof eyeliner with a fine enough tip for precise tightlining.

I purchased the Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Waterline Eyeliner Pencil – color Tootsie (cool medium brown matte). I wanted to try this because I was using another product (not Urban Decay) that also stated it was formulated for the waterline and discovered it didn’t work for me as I expected. The color is rich and applies easily. The description states that it’s waterproof and that is true in that I was only able to remove it using an eye makeup remover. However, I found that the product does not stay on for 24 hours on the waterline, but it did remain on longer than other products I’ve tried. So, keep this in mind. It also states that it’s smudge resistant and transfer resistant and that is also true as I did apply it to the corner of my lower lid, and it only smudged slightly after I purposefully attempted several times to make it smudge. So, in my opinion, unless you are constantly rubbing your eyes, you won’t have any problems with smudging on your skin. Additionally, in my experience, ensure that you use a sharpener that is specifically made for eyeliner pencils. In the past I’ve tried using a pencil sharpener that’s made for a pencil that’s used for writing, and it did not work at all. The only thing that happened was that the tip continually broke. Overall, I like the Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliner pencil. The color that I purchased was true to the description, and it was easy to apply. Based on the color and ease of application I would say the product is of higher quality therefore the price is reasonable. However, as stated above, the eyeliner did not remain on my waterline for 24 hours, but it did remain on my upper and lower lids for 24 hours.

The best waterline pencil out there

This eyeliner is great! Goes on smooth and stays all day. I have oily skin and my eyelids touch the top of my eyes. The eyeliner stays all day and I live in SW Florida so it’s HOT and still no problems. TIP: When you want to sharpen your pencil put it in the freezer for about an hour BEFORE you sharpen it. You get a nice sharp point without a problem.

The eyeliner is amazing and it stays on really well. The problem is when you have to sharpen it. It is frustrating because every time I do, I lose alot of product.

Very good, just what I would expect from this brand

My eyes is oily it stillspread to eyebag ..so.not really for waterline

Don’t even question this product. I have been using it for so many years and it’s my go to no matter what especially on a long night out. This gift from god to women is truly that. It stays on. It’s soooo black.. and it glides so nicely. I love it. Love it so much that I have one in every purse. Trust me… I don’t lie. I would gift this to every women alive if I could. Xoxo

Best eyeliner I’ve ever used. It stays put until washed off.

Very pigmented and very smooth when applying, doesn’t ‘catch’ the skin. Will definitely buy again.