Montinaro Cap Toe Mens Oxford

This is a well made shoe. I have wide feet and this shoe was too pointy to fit me comfortably.

Decent quality shoe for the sub-$100 level. Compared to some of the Bostonians I have purchased, the leather is softer and less shiny/plasticy, and feels like a higher priced shoe. It will interesting to see how the sole holds up, which seems to be some sort of leather-like material, but I do prefer the looks over a rubber sole.My one complaint is that I purchased a 3E and it is barely wide enough for my foot. I feel like I have worn regular D-width shoes that are this wide. It does work for me, but I was surprised to see how narrow it is for a 3E. Also, be aware that the shoe is a bit longer and more pointy than I anticipated based on the photos. I am fine with the shape, but was surprised.Overall, I am quite happy with the purchase and will be looking for more Florsheim shoes for the future.

I wear a 10.5 regular shoe and got these in a 10 and they fit perfect. This is my second pair of these in black. The bottom on my first pair cracked. I wear them regularly Mon-Fri and have a identical pair, but in brown that I also wear. The brown pair was bought at the same time as the first black pair and did not crack. I chalked it up to a bad pair so I bought another pair in black. I got them in September 2019 and they have since held up. They look nice and work with business casual or suits.

I have a wider foot and a small arch and these fit great right out of the box. Wore them to a wedding the day after I got them and didn’t even need to be broken in. 100% recommend!

Looks wide but it’s comfortable

I've bought these shoes three times now. I love the way they fit and feel, but unfortunately they do not last. I work in restaurants and they tend to get abused. I think each pair has lasted 6 to 8 months before the soles start wearing out. You can't beat the price for the fit and looks. Watch out if you walk on a wet or damp surface. These things are like ice skates. If you wear these once a week and or work in a carpeted office, then they'll last you a long time. Maybe next time I'll actually spend the money and get a pair that will last and can be resoled... and then again, maybe not.

Excellent support

I bought these shoes through Amazon Wardrobe, looking for a nice pair of medium brown shoes for my son's wedding. I like the option to try before you buy. The minute I tried these shoes on with my navy suit, I knew I found the right pair!Quality is good, comfort is excellent, style was spot on. Very glad I bought these shoes!!

I wear size 12 and have feet that are a bit wide. I always have trouble finding dress shoes that are a good fit and also comfortable. Most dress shoes are way too big because the toe area extends too far out, and on a size 12 shoe that means it's really hard to walk up stairs and other things because it's so long. I didn't have that problem with these shoes; perfect fit and the sole is very comfortable. My only complaint is that it's a bit scuffed at the front after wearing it a few days already. I hope the quality won't be an issue.

Florsheim used to be a great brand. Not anymore.These a cemented construction with fake stitching. The sole is made with cheap "leather" that split horizontally after a dozen wears.Avoid.

I bought this at a discounted price and it is good value for money. My size is 9.5 and this fits a little bigger. The upper leather is not as fine as I expected but I am hoping Floreshiem product will live up to its quality expectations, fingers crossed.

My husband loves these shoes. He has bought 3 pairs in the last few years, 2 in saddle tan color and 1 in black. He finds the shoes comfortable and they fit his wide feet.

Leather is an acceptable quality for a Florsheim product, however the upper lacing is easy to snap of you aren’t delicate with it or like tugging on laces often. Had to switch a new set of laces in after two months of heavy use. Shoe is of okay quality if you can get it on sale.