Trader Joe'sCreamy Salted Peanut Butter From Unblanched Peanuts-SET OF 2

I bought two of these peanut butter, it was a twin pack. The peanut butter was just like soup, I shook it well, then I stirred it well. I tasted it and the taste was good. I tried using it on crackers and it was a joke. I finally placed it in the Refridgerator overnight. It did harden enough to smoothly spread but I could see I used more than expected or something because it was 3/4 full. I don't use much peanut butter so it had to be the consistency. I didn't really read the name and think about it but it kinda fits, trader joe, lol