e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black

Loves this. It goes on well and stays on all day. The pointed end means you can do a flick easily if you want to.

I love this liner and I wear it everyday, it doesn't really smudge, I love that it doesn't require sharpening and it doesn't snap off bits on your eyelids like some pencils do. I can make a nice neat wing and it lasts all day but also comes off nicely with makeup remover or baby wipes.

It definitely does budge! Not waterproof and smears easily. But its easy to use and pigment is high quality

Love this eye liner, easy to use, good colour selection. Would recommend

I have always struggled to find a eyeliner that does not leak and give me panda eyes. I was hopeful this would work. It goes on lovely but sadly it does budge. Would not recommend for Panda eyed people

at last an eyeliner that does what it says on the tin. Very soft and easy to apply and lasts till I take it off!

Ordered after seeing so many reviews that elf eyeliner is smudge proof but after applying this liner with in 3 hours liner smudges all over my eyes though all my makeup ruined as I applied very confidently and went for shopping , waste of £5 , now it says can’t return an item

Really good! Survives a long day of teaching and walking in the rain, I'm impressed