Wet n Wild, Megalast Retractable Eyeliner, Gel Eyeliner with Intense Finish and Long-lasting Effect for 16 Hours, Makeup for Eyes, Pigmented and Stain-proof Formula, Black Brown

I don’t know if I got a bad batch, but even when freshly opened this eyeliner barely made a mark around my skin. I tried to apply over and over again and the best result I got was a very faint grey line with a few black clumps in it. Wouldn’t recommend

I saw all the positive reviews and thought this would be good. Its really messy and breaks so I will not be buying again

Good quality.