Cold Steel Handmade Carbon Steel Scottish Dirk Sword Replica with Secure Leather Scabbard, 13 Inch Blade

I saw a few recent reviews claiming the handle was plastic, not rosewood. Those reviewers are absolutely wrong. They need to check themselves if they cannot tell the difference. I scratched the handle to be sure, and sure enough the red wood popped through. It's clearly wood. Dont be fooled by an idiot who cant tell plastic from wood. The knife is solid. It comes with the crap indian bevel that needs to be changed, and with an hour worth of sharpening to change it, it now is acceptable. I withheld one star for that. The handle is very secure. I've taken the dirk out and punished it cutting alder and it cuts like a hatchet. Using this as a bush craft knife works well. It holds up well. The weight is perfect for chopping. The frog is meant for a 4" kilt belt. If you use a regular belt, you'll need it modified. It is not great leather, but has held solid so far. The knife hangs edge backward, which sucks. Dirks are traditionally carried edge forward for the fight ready ice pick hold. Modification leaves the stitching facing out. That is a minus, but it is what it is. The scabbard fits snug. There are two flaps of plastic inside the scabbard that holds the knife in place even when jogged upside down. The blade comes very well greased. The factory grease wipes off easily. This is not stainless, so dont be a fool and treat it as it is. Oil your blade with gun oil of your choice and it will stay nice. In all, I recommend. For bushcraft, it's a great knife and will hold up to any reasonable request you ask of it. For everyday carry, I like it and have no issues. For gutting and skinning, it's not that type of blade. It will dispatch, but be prepared to switch to a dedicated skinner. Update: I bought another one...

I ordered this because I've always wanted one and I was not disappointed! This blade is dang near perfect; razor sharp, well made, sturdy, and fit nice in my hand. The sheath is wood, metal and leather, and while not as nice as the Dirk itself, it's functional. Note that this is not a toy or for playing around; this is a functional blade. I couldn't be happier with it!

Let's face it--New Year's is okay, but the thing to which most people are really looking forward at that time of year is a Rabbie Burns Supper. Right? Right?! For those who don't know (read: everyone who isn't Scottish), a Burns Supper is a dinner held every year sometime around late January to celebrate the life of Robert ("Rabbie") Burns, the National Poet of Scotland, who died in 1796. It is a night of whisky, poetry, ribaldry, and, of course, the one other thing for which Scotland is (in)famous: haggis. As we all know, haggis is the Scottish version of meatloaf, "containing sheep's pluck (heart, liver, and lungs), minced with chopped onion, oatmeal, suet, spices, and salt, mixed with stock, and cooked while traditionally encased in the animal's stomach." Yum. So what does any of this have to do with a big-ass fighting knife? Well, one of the highlights of a Burns Supper is the ceremonial setting on fire and subsequent ritual disembowelment of the haggis, and it's this last part where a good dirk comes in handy. I recommend the Cold Steel Scottish Dirk for that role. A little about this bad boy: the blade is 13" long, forged--not stamped from 1055 steel, which a medium carbon steel. The blade comes very sharp, so be careful, and also has a groove just under the top edge. Is it really there for "blood" or is it just to lighten/stiffen the blade? No one is sure; I just know that it looks cool. The blade also comes with a sheen of machine oil, so if you are planning on using it to stab a haggis, make sure you remove the oil and wash the blade first! The grip is Rosewood hand-carved into a traditional shape and design. Yes, it's real wood; anyone telling you different is just wrong. In short, this is an impressive tool/weapon and one can easily imagine using it in a number of different situations. As many have noted, the sheath ain't that great, and that's a real shame. It's not that it's completely horrid, but it looks and feels cheaply made (because it is) and you will definitely have to be careful when sheathing the dirk. I'll tell you what, though--the dirk and sheath look awesome when paired with someone wearing formal Scottish wear. And that's why I got this, as a gift for a Scottish friend dressed in a full formal kilt who was performing the haggis murder at a Burns Supper. His eyes lit up and the grin was ear-to-ear as he attached the dirk to his belt. It just fit, like it had been there all along, as it has for Scotsmen for hundreds of years. Talk about completing the look! Sort of makes you realize why the English made the Scots swear oaths on their dirks; it was the most important thing to them for a long, long time. So whether you're thinking about the Cold Steel Scottish Dirk for attacking meatloaf, as a big camp knife, or just because you like edged weapons, this is a pretty cool blade to have. It's solidly built, very impressive, and a good bargain at this price. Do it!

Very well made, good quality Dirk. No complaints.

This dirk is great! It takes a very sharp edge and is easy to resharpen. It's carbon not stainless so keep it clean and oiled. It seems very tough I've used it as a machiettie with no damage and it's still sharp enough to pry splinters out of your fingers. I've not experienced any problems with the sheath, which is attractive, tirmed in metal, quiet and sturdy. Maybe they have corrected the problems mentioned by other reviewers.

Great product. Well worth the price. the handle doesn't even feel like wood and the brass inserts are all still on it. The blade is sharpened on one side and the other side has a long and short blood groove. The sheath is nice black leather with a metal throat and tip. It hangs from a belt quite nicely. The thing could definitely take some serious abuse and come out fine. The only down side is that the sheet has a plastic insert to hold the blade in place. It's nice, but it kinda pushes the blade into the throat as it goes in. Not really a big deal, but I had to find at least one downside. This knife is awesome. Buy it!

It’s smaller than what it looks like on YouTube videos. It’s a cool piece 👍🏻 for a good price compared to the Cold Steel dragonfly tanto. It’s just a wall hanger for me so I can’t speak about using it for bushcraft. Update I really like it. Mine came sharp. The only flaw is the sheath doesn’t dangle very well. But it’s a cool piece..

As I have come to expect with all my Cold Steel blades, this blade appears to be well-designed and well-made. The sheath? Not so much. In fact, the sheath is crappy and cheap - to the point that is more resembles what you would get with a child's toy sword rather than something in which to carry a wickedly sharp blade. 1. As you can see, the lining inside the sheath is loose and inhibits the smooth insertion of the blade. In fact, I have yet to find a way to insert the blade into the sheath on a single try. Only gently placing the point of the blade on the very edge of the locket can the blade be inserted into the sheath at all. 2. Even when I get the blade into the sheath, there is no good fit between the quillon and locket. (A) There is a gap of approximately 2 mm between the quillon and locket and (B) the sheath is about 1.5 degrees off true. Therefore - 3 stars. 5 stars for the blade and 0 stars for the sheath. I have very disappointed. I have other Cold Steel blades and the quality and workmanship of both the blades and the sheaths has been superb. This, however, is a stinker. The poor quality of the sheath is making me rethink other Cold Steel purchases I have plans for. If it were not for the fact that this is indeed a well-crafted blade I would send it back.

COLD STEEL Scottish Dirk / 18-3/8" Overall / 13" Blade / 1/4" Thick / 1055 Carbon Steel / 5-3/8" Rosewood Handle/Leather Scabbard / 16 OZ I received this item today (Oct. 06, 2025) it's beautiful and well made and has some heft to it. Is it sharp, well . . . let me tell you, when unwrapping and trying to get the plastic bag off of the dirk, it was stuck to the bag with the grease on the blade, After getting it out of the bag and inspecting it, to my surprise my finger was bleeding, it's was so sharp that I did not feel the cut, that's how sharp it is!. The handle felt very nice in my hand and when putting it back in the scabbard, it will only fit one way, with the scabbard facing up, the sharp edge should be facing to the right side of the scabbard. Dirk with scabbard, weight is 1.18 oz. without scabbard 1.11 oz. I am one happy customer with this dirk.

I have seen multiple reviews of the Cold Steel dirk, so I'd read about concerns other customers found. Yes, the blade comes heavily greased, but a carbon steel blade is far better greasy than rusty. Yes, the black on the handle bleeds; I will figure out a way either to remove the bleeding dye or fix it. Those are minor concerns. Far more importantly, my dirk came sharp out of the box. It has a very heavy spine, the fullers on both sides of the blade are deep, clean and - to my eye, anyway - symmetrical. My dirk's blade seems to be well-fitted; so far I've found no issues with rattle or looseness. The pin work on the handle is attractive. The scabbard fittings are clean and subtle in black. This is a working blade, just what I wanted, and definitely is *not* a wall-hanger. It will look fine, not gaudy, on my right hip when I am wearing my kilt at formal functions.

The Dirk was made very solid and very sharp out of the box. But, it was clearly a return. The tape on the box was cut and replaced. The Dirk was extremely dirty as if it used last year to cut the Haggis and never washed, then returned for a refund. I may add that the paint on the handle rubbed off on my hand. I had to add a clear coat to it.

Awsome

well, the dirk itself is quite good. Sharp right out of the package.However, the sheath left much and more to be desired.As soon as I took the sheath out of the box, the top of the sheath slid of the main frame.Really poor job of securing it.It had a piece of plastic in the mouth of the sheath to prevent the dirk from slipping out of it's sheath.Not exactly a period piece.(I re-enact the War of 1812- a dirk would havve been found with Scotts Regiments including the Glengarries). The handle is quite well made with the rosewood handle. I'm not quite decided on the metal bolsters, perhaps period, perhaps not.all in All, if you don't mind shoddy craftmanship with the sheath, it's worth while. (I'm fortunate enough to know someone who is able to hand craft a much more fitting sheath.