Aneley's Natural Organic Gel Eye Liner

I've been a gel liner user for years until recently my eyelids developed some sensitivity to the brands i normally use (Bobbi Brown/Sephora/MAC etc etc). It started giving me red dry itchy skin towards the inner corners of my eyes and stayed persistent for over a month. I tried many other eyeliners and this is the first that didn't irritate my eyelids at all and now my eyes have healed and went back to normal. Truly a life saver! I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 because it does tend to cake up if you use too much and will feel chalky once dried. Long wearing and looks great even at the end of the day without any touchups.