Gabriel Cosmetics Classic Eyeliner (Navy), Natural Eye Liner, Paraben Free, Vegan, Gluten-free, Cruelty- free, Non GMO, long lasting, Infused with Jojoba Seed Oil, Super Smooth formula, 0.04 Oz.

The eyeliner works well and as it is a pencil that can be sharpened lasts a long time. It didn't come with a sharpener but I had one that worked. Love that it is all natural without parabens. I love the charcoal as it is not as starkly black as black.

I have used this eye pencil for about 1 year without any negative reactions at all. I was having so many allergy problems including itchy scaly eyelid skin. As part of the changes I made in dealing with allergies, I searched for cosmetic products that did not include chemicals and tried several of the Gabriel line and I am totally happy with the results and will continue to use these products as long as they stay true to the way they are making their products. This pencil goes on smooth and has a good, true black color. I put a small amount of powered dark brown eye shadow on the line I have made with this pencil and it stays on all day. I also use this pencil for my eyebrows with great results.

eyeliner & eyebrow can both be used due to appropriate color.

love gabriel for being vegan and cruelty free but will stick with elf .. too dry and hard to apply .

This is the best eyeliner color and quality of pencil that I've ever used. It is a subtle grayish-green. Gives a very natural look with enough green to it to make my blue eyes "pop". The pencil goes on smooth. Not too hard. Not too soft. Just right and stays well until taken off. Great ingredients as well.

This is not as smooth as advertised. I would assume that a color that is labeled as charcoal should be black not gray.

This is my go-to eyeliner. I went back from another super popular brand to this because the other one doesn’t wash off as easily. This could be a con for a lot of people so be aware.This smudges and lightens throughout the day. But I personally like that. It gives me a smoky look without looking like melted trash by the end of the day. I love that I can easily wash this off too and sharpen when needed. This needed less frequent sharpening compared to the other super popular brand that I used to love.I got charcoal this time as opposed to the brown that I used to get and I think I like the brown a little better on me. But definitely love this brand of eyeliner pencil!

I like that the color of the pencil eyeliner is clear and strong. but. my eyes are very sensitive, and always I'm using vegan pencil eyeliner, but, it doesn't look like this item is vegan, because when I lined my eyes it starts etching and turn to red and I'm going to return it back. sorry