MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounce JarUSDA Organic

This peanut butter and I? We’re in a committed relationship. I've ordered it several times now and even took the plunge into a subscribe-and-save delivery—because why risk running out of something this good? That’s a level of loyalty I usually reserve for coffee and sweatpants.Let’s talk ingredients: they’re clean and minimal, just what you want in a pantry staple. No sneaky palm oil or mystery additives here—just real, organic peanut goodness. It’s the kind of label that makes you feel like you made a responsible adult decision without even trying too hard.Now, fair warning: this peanut butter is very runny. Like, "Did I accidentally buy peanut soup?" kind of runny. But hear me out—it works perfectly for my morning routine. I drizzle it right into my hot oatmeal, and it melts like a dream. No clumps, no stirring tantrums, just creamy, nutty bliss in every bite.If you’re someone who eats peanut butter with a spoon straight from the jar, this might take a little finesse (maybe refrigerate it for a bit). But if you’re using it in smoothies, oatmeal, baking, or anything where spreadability isn't a must, this texture is a feature, not a flaw.The jar is a decent size, though honestly, mine doesn’t last long. Between breakfast, baking, and the occasional midnight “just a taste” spoonful, it goes quick—which is why the auto-delivery subscription was the only logical next step.Final verdict? If you’re into real ingredients, smooth (but not thick) texture, and flavor that actually tastes like roasted peanuts—not sugar, not chemicals—this is the one. Just stir it well, store it wisely, and prepare to wonder how you ever settled for the artificial stuff.

The media could not be loaded. Love this peanut butter! I was torn between this peanut butter, organic Jif, and the Justin’s brand. I ruled out the other two based on ingredients and the nutritional facts. I noticed that MaraNatha’s peanut butter had more protein, less fat, and less carbs compared to the other competitors. The texture was smooth and not grainy. I don’t feel like it produces as many oils at the top like other organic peanut butters, so it is not as watery; however it is pretty liquidy (see video). The main reason I got it was for my smoothies so the liquidy part doesn’t affect me, in fact I think it’s easier to blend for smoothies. I don’t feel like the peanut better was as salty either. Just comparing their ingredients and nutritional facts to other peanut butters was what got me to try MaraNatha peanut butter and I don’t think I’ll go back to Justin’s after this.

I truly must've missed the labeling on this product when I added it to the basket, so I'll blame myself for that, but I was looking forward to trying it. I think the taste is fine but, if I'd wanted Peanut Butter Soup, I'd slide back down to Virginia (Colonial Williamsburg) and go to the Kings' Arms Tavern and request a bowl of their Peanut Soup with some Sally Lund bread. Even after several days in the fridge, you could literally 'pour' this product right out of the jar. When I used a bread knife to stir and, it takes quite a bit of stirring, the 'Spread' ran down the knife while trying to move it over to the bread. Really disappointed, first of all that anyone would want to put their name on this product and also, why? Why is it necessary to make peanut butter so runny? A 'Spread' is supposed to 'spread'. I honestly tried to make it work but then I just got upset that they would sell me something like that and laugh all the way to the bank. I buy only organic, single ingredient unless salt is added b/c of my dogs so I spent a bit of time researching the products available on Amazon and thought this was a reliable company/product. I do not recommend unless you want a runny peanut butter flavored mess.

This is hands down the best peanut butter I've ever eaten. The perfect consistency, and no added crap. So yummy and I love it.

Nice flavor, no sugar, no added oils so they say.. & it's organic, a must for me nowadays. But this peanut butter is very runny making me think it might be cut with some sort of un-declared oil. Had it before and it was thicker, which works better on crackers. This time I had to eat it with a spoon... hence only 4 stars

This stuff is a liquid at room temp and even chilled is very runny. More of a sauce than a butter, can be easily poured. Tastes good but not really something you can spoon out of the jar without it dripping everywhere. A peanut butter sandwich would be impossible but you could pour it into batter for cookies, etc.

Great to have on hand. Clean ingredients and healthy. Love the spreadability and texture.

Great product- delicious- wish it were in a glass jar. I would pay for xtra for that!