Starry Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Gel with Brush Black Asphalt, 3g/0.11oz

This is the best gel eyeliner that I have tried. It is easily applied to the brush and eye. It goes on dark, however I usually do two coats to make it crisp. It last all day and looks wonderful. The only problem is that it tends to smudge if rubbed. If you do not rub you will have no problems at all.

The liner goes on like a dream and a little goes a long way. My issues is it smudges and smears within application! Not even smudge as in, mild normal corner of the eye. This stuff creates a mirror image arc on my lids from where the liner touches my brow when my eyes are open. It's really too bad because it goes on amazingly but comes off and gets all over the place. Not only that but a $1 liner pencil can do a better job!!!MONEY BACK PLEASE!!!

It works, but it is not long lasting. By the end of the work day, I look like I have raccoon eyes. The color is correct, but the texture of the product is a little greasy, and smears so easily. If you use it to line the bottom, be aware if any of the liner gets on your lashes, you will have lash marks on your face all day.

This liner does smudge quite a bit, but I have figured out that if you wet the brush and apply it sparsely as you would with watercolor, it doesn't smudge at all and you still get a rich color.

I have asymmetrical eyes. My right eye has a slight thicker double-lid than my left eye. So, I always find it so hard to use eyeliner pencils to make 'em look the same. But with this product, it takes whole a lot of stress off from my shoulders by providing smooth and precise application. The brush is much easier to handle on my eyes, and it really last long. However, when you first apply it on your eyes, it's crucial that you dry them off, or else, that gel will get all over the place. Try to dip just the tip of your brush into the gel so that you can get the minimum amount of gel on it. Over dipping will make it harder for you to not get smudged.

This is a great price for the quality. Very dark and applies easily.Ihave used maybelline, Loreal, rimmel, elf, and covergirl gel eye liners and to me this is just as good. I can sleep with this on and it stays. I can wear this all day long and no need to reapply! Love this stuff and this is my 3rd purchase of it!

This eyeliner SMEARS everywhere!! It is extremely messy, not recommended at all! I thought I could use a cheaper brand and get the same results as department brands, but sad to say that is not the case. I gave this eyeliner a chance, but sadly it was tossed in the garbage and immediately I went to Nordy's to purchase my MAC.

Great for price! this is exactly like maybellines gel eyeliner that is $10! This product lasted me a over a year for only $2!