8.4 oz. Organic Body Butter - Vanilla Lavender

I'm on the fence about this body butter. The texture is creamy and it smells great until the after-smell hits you, which reminds me of sweaty socks. Not to mention it makes my skin itchy after putting it on. I've used it twice. I'm not sure if I can return it since it's been used and it seems too much of a hassle to try.